Monday, September 23, 2013

On testing the way the wind blows

A few days ago, former Deputy Chief Minister of Bihar Sushil Kumar Modi reportedly tweeted: “Advaniji has failed to gauge the public mood”. He said LK Advani should have declared Narendra Modi as the BJP’s Prime Ministerial candidate for the coming general election.

It is no secret that 'Advaniji' had held prime ministerial hopes for over twenty years, and now it’s too late. His brand of politics has been sharpened to rapier point by younger men. So he has had to finally endorse Narendra Modi at public rallies.

Let us, for a moment, forget who is less suitable between the two men. Instead, let’s examine Sushil Modi’s lobbing of unsolicited 140-character chunks of advice at 'Advaniji'.

On the face of it, this sounds like good advice. In a democracy, elections are a reflection of public will. If people are discontent and thirsting for change, they’ll let you know. And it is true that a politician ceases to be significant if he disregards the electorate. A good politician is aware of, and sensitive to, the public mood.

But the problem with Sushil Modi’s advice is that it reduces leadership to mere politicking. It takes away from a politician the right to be a leader. It expects a politician to bow to ideas that please a sufficient number of people in order to win an election, and trample upon truth and Constitutional rights lest he/she is punished with powerlessness. In effect, it reduces a leader to an unthinking, spineless slave of the majority view (or whatever passes for the majority).

I don’t know if Advani’s misgivings about Narendra Modi’s leadership are moral. I doubt this. But I also think that our leaders owe us a personal moral compass. We need them to stand up for their own beliefs rather than just kowtow to the ‘public mood’.

Where have all our true leaders gone? This is our constant complaint. We imagine governance as a ship lost at sea. We think of politicians as wicked pirates (except they’re not fighting fit). But we forget what goes into the making of true leaders.

Think of the men and women whose names went into history textbooks for steering modern India through her independence struggle. MK Gandhi survived (and ultimately fell to) assassination attempts, not by the British but by Indians, who did not like his ideas on caste or religion. In nineteenth century India, notions of pollution-purity were the norm. Most leaders were upper caste and most of the country was illiterate. If public approval was all they sought, they would never have endorsed universal suffrage.

Inter-communal marriage was very rare in the 1920s. But Aruna Asaf Ali chose to risk public antagonism for the sake of her own values. Leaders like C Rajagopalachari risked political exile when they walked away from the party they helped to build.

It is not the job of a leader to be the public. A leader represents us, yes, but he/she must work for more than public approval. The job description includes upholding the Constitution; enforcing laws; making laws for a future; rejecting what is unworthy in our present; making justice a broader, more humane reality.

Sometimes this means being in conflict with the majority. If 51% of India wanted that 49% be turned into landless labourers with no access to drinking water, should a leader care about ‘public mood’? What if it’s 65% and 35%? What if it’s 78% and 22%? When does it become right to allow ‘public mood’ to dictate political decisions?

A good leader is someone willing to work to reshape popular ideas, redirect public energy and risk public displeasure. As far as gauging the public mood goes, any politician can do that.

[A version of this was published in DNA]


Scooze said...

Hi Annie,

A big hello from Scooze!

I'm Shantanu, co-founder of Scooze - a New Delhi based startup. Scooze ( is a platform which helps people run their own web magazines on topics they love.

We love your blog, so we've created a sample magazine of your blog posts on Scooze. You can see it here - Do let us know if you like it (or don't). :-)

As a successful blogger, you can use your Scooze magazine to....

1. Help new readers discover your blog
2. Engage your readers by curating videos, blogs, news stories you like from across the web in your Scooze magazine
3. Discover great stories by subscribing to other magazines on Scooze

We'd be honored if you'd...
1. Make your own magazine on Scooze
2. Be part of our 'Early Adopters' user group

Would you be interested in being one of Scooze's early users? Do let us know.

Thanks and happy scoozing!

The team @ Scooze
Ravi, Aashutosh, Shashank n Shantanu

Reply to me at

Call me at +91 9717300782

My LinkedIn Profile:

Tushar Mangl said...

But what will be a leader achieve in real terms if he or she has zero support from their constituents. A leader has to have followers and followers have to have a leader.

unknown said...

Hi there we would love to have a writer for if you are interested please email us at

Anonymous said...

Hey Annie...

Guess what, Found you! I'm the lady you met in the auto while your stay in Lucknow...
Read most of you posts.. and I'm overwhelmed to have met you...
Thinking of buying your reportage book by this weekend...
Do keep in touch...
I did my first graduation with majors in English Literature from Presidency college, Kolkata... I'm too much in love with poetry and fiction by my set of favourites...
Feels really great to have known a writer like you, even for few mins.

Had a blog earlier which got deleted owing to a secret hack attempt..
Please do read my humble attempts at poetry and stuff, if you want to... I'm surely gonna read yours :)

Links :


Tweets by @anniezaidi